Close Menu
The Central Wire
  • Home
  • News
  • Editorial
  • Business
  • Sci-Tech
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Markets
  • Automotive
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech Reviews
Facebook
The Central WireThe Central Wire
Subscribe
Friday, June 6
  • Home
  • News
  • Editorial
  • Business
  • Sci-Tech
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
The Central Wire
  • Home
  • News
  • Editorial
  • Business
  • Sci-Tech
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
Home - Business News - Could Sebi’s new curbs for investment advisors choke financial planning in India?
SEBI
SEBI Office

Could Sebi’s new curbs for investment advisors choke financial planning in India?

Business News 22/08/2024Dhuleswar GarnayakBy Dhuleswar Garnayak5 Mins Read

The move has sparked widespread concern among advisers, who fear it could signal the end of holistic financial planning and undermine the comprehensiveness of their services.

Contents

Toggle
  • the challenge
  • Regulation overhaul
  • Advisor backlash
  • finding a balance

the challenge

Most people seeking financial guidance turn to an investment advisor for a complete plan that covers everything from mutual funds to tax and estate planning. Now, this comprehensive approach is under threat with Sebi proposing to limit these services under the investment advisor (IA) license.

If advisors wished to continue offering such services, they would need to do so through separate legal entities and under different branding.

Regulation overhaul

In a consultation paper, Sebi proposed that investment advisors should no longer offer services like tax planning, estate planning, loan management, real estate, gold, or bitcoin under their IA license. Sebi’s reasoning: these products are either unregulated or fall outside its jurisdiction, making it difficult to address client complaint related to such offerings.

However, for services or products regulated by other authorities, investment advisors can continue to operate, provided the grievances are handled by the respective regulator.

Also read | How Sebi’s reforms could transform India’s investment advisory landscape

For example, grievances related to fixed deposits are managed by Reserve Bank of India, those related to the National Pension Scheme by the Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority, and insurance-related grievances by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority.

While Sebi aims to distance itself from unregulated products and those overseen by other authorities, RIAs can continue to offer general asset allocation advice, such as advising clients to allocate a portion of their savings to various asset classes.

However, Sebi does not want them to actively manage these assets or handle tax planning under the IA license.

(Mint Graphics)

View Full Image

(Mint Graphics)

Advisor backlash

When the IA regulations were introduced in 2013, Sebi included “financial planning” as part of investment advice. Consequently, many people opted for the IA license specifically to offer comprehensive financial planning.

Now, Sebi aims to remove “financial planning” from the scope of the license directing advisors to focus solely on managing regulated assets.

“We provide what our clients want and they expect us to provide 360-degree financial plan,” Renu Maheshwari, a registered investment advisor and vice chair of the Association of Registered Investment Advisors (ARIA), said.

If an investment advisor only focuses on specific products without considering the entire financial picture, it amounts to just selling a product, she said. “Investment advisory is a part of financial planning and Sebi is looking the other way around.”

A financial plan typically considers a client’s income, debt, homeownership, tax liability, and other factors to determine suitable investments.

“If I don’t advise on insurance products or risk management, while doing investment advisory, then I would miss out on what other risks a client is taking,” added Maheshwari. “The regulator is looking at a jurisdiction-centric approach, while we are looking at a client-centric solution.”

The textbook definition of financial planning comprises various aspects of a person’s financial life, such as education funding, insurance, taxes, and estate planning. Additionally, most investment advisors provide advice on international stocks or employee stock options in global companies.

However, Sebi’s consultation paper proposes to exclude such assets from the investment advisers’ scope, as they are either unregulated or overseen by foreign regulators.

Suresh Sadagopan, an investment advisor and founder of Ladder7 Financial Advisories, argued that creating a financial plan for an individual using separate entities would be excessively cumbersome. “It will become a hassle and not possible to create multiple entities to cater to the needs of a single client.”

Harsh Roongta, an RIA and founder of Fee-Only Investment Advisors, stated that Sebi’s concern about complaints related to unregulated products and those overseen by other entities is disproportionate.

Also read | How Sebi is cracking down on unregistered investment advisors

According to data compiled by the Association of Registered Investment Advisors (ARIA), 73% of the complaints received by Sebi since the introduction of RIA regulations were about trading call providers, and only 1% were related to advisory services. (see infographic)

“I believe futures and options (F&O) advisory should not be allowed under RIA licensing because that’s where most of the complaints are coming from,” added Roongta.

Additionally complaints on unregulated products or those not overseen by the markets regulator are not separately tracked.

finding a balance

Several registered investment advisors suggested that it would be perhaps be better to provide clear disclosures to clients that Sebi will not offer recourse for unregulated products, rather than requiring the creation of separate entities for advising on different products or services.

Roongta said that in developed markets such as the US, despite a complicated regulatory environment, there was no such stringent requirement for financial planners.

He also noted that Sebi allows part-time advisors to provide unregulated services with a disclaimer that these activities fall outside Sebi’s regulations.

Interestingly, Sebi has proposed allowing part-time advisors, including those with non-finance backgrounds, to serve up to 75 clients as part of the same consultation paper.

Roongta suggested that full-time RIAs offering financial planning should also be ideally receive the same treatment and Sebi should consider it.

“A client comes to one person to get comprehensive financial advice. If it’s broken up into two separate pieces, the offering would get fractured,” Roongta added. “Managing it through two entities could spell the end of comprehensive financial planning.”

Another possible solution would be for Sebi to white-list certain services, such as tax planning, wills and estate planning, while blacklisting more risky products within financial planning.

Sebi has also collected feedback from RIAs and is expected to revisit its proposals before finalizing the regulations.

Advisors expect the markets regulator to address their concerns and that the new rules will better accommodate comprehensive financial planning.

Dhuleswar Garnayak
Dhuleswar Garnayak

Dhuleswar Garnayak is a seasoned journalist with extensive expertise in international relations, business news, and editorials. With a keen understanding of global dynamics and a sharp analytical mind, Dhuleswar provides readers with in-depth coverage of complex international issues and business developments. His editorial work is known for its insightful analysis and thought-provoking commentary, making him a trusted voice in understanding the intersections of global affairs and economic trends.

advisors choke curbs financial financial planning financial planning in India financial planning industry financial planning regulations financial planning services in India India India financial services financial planning services investment investment advisor licensing investment advisors investment advisory services planning registered investment advisors RIA regulations SEBI Sebi consultation paper Sebi guidelines Sebi regulations Sebis
Previous ArticlePVR Inox promoters including Ajay Bijli trim stake in the company; sell 0.33% stake via open market
Next Article Prasar Bharati’s OTT ambition: Can India’s public broadcaster compete in a crowded market?

Keep Reading

LIC Digital Transformation: 5 Bold Moves for Future Growth

Torrent Power’s ₹64,000 Crore Push to Green Energy Revolution

Kenya’s $1.3B Power Deal with Adani Sparks Controversy

DMCA.com Protection Status
World At a Glance

Ireland Hate Speech Law Shelved After Controversy

22/09/2024

Russian Airstrike Hits Kharkiv, Injuring 12 Civilians

22/09/2024

Ukraine War: Russia Rejects Peace Talks in Diplomatic Blow

22/09/2024

France Right-Wing Government Rises Amid Political Deadlock

22/09/2024

Ukraine War: Allies’ Support Key to Victory, Zelenskyy Warns

22/09/2024
Trending Now

Armani/Caffè Debuts in Mumbai, Redefining Luxury Dining

13/09/2024

Friday the 13th: Superstition, History, and the Internet’s Obsession

13/09/2024

Paris Paralympics 2024: India’s Record 29 Medals Achieved

09/09/2024

All the Winners (and EGOTs) of the 2024 Creative Arts Emmys

09/09/2024

Gillian Anderson’s Evolution: From Iconic TV Star to Advocate for Women’s Sexual Liberation

09/09/2024
TCW LOGO
  • World Today
  • India Today
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Gadgets Review
  • Car Review
  • Bike Review
  • Mobile Review
  • Tablet review
  • Editorials
  • Opinion
  • Editor's Choice
  • Explained
  • Trending Now
© 2025 The Central Wire or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.